Re: Crack repairing with pumping suction cups?
Posted: March 8th, 2009, 12:34 pm
In my short two plus decades in WSR I've used four techniques for repairing cracks up to 36 or so inches (although I've repaired cracks up to 63 inches long):
1. Injecting the resin under pressure with a bridge and injector, watching the resin travel as far as the pressure would allow (roughly four inches), drilling again, injecting again, etc, etc. Obviously not a recommended practice. I quit using that technique about 1988 or 89.
2. Drilling the tip, injecting resin, observing how far the resin traveled and then continuing on by running the dropper tip of the resin bottle along the crack. This is a very messy technique and wastes an enormous amount of resin (not that your resin supplier would complain). I learned to somewhat compensate for the wasted resin by catching the drips with a razor blade and feeding the resin to the crack by moving the blade. Overall, this technique demonstrates inconsistent results. In order for it to work you need a crack that's sufficiently surfaced along it's entire length so that the resin can wick into the damage by capillary action. Curves and "zig-zaggy" areas generally are too tight for capillary action to work although sometimes you get lucky.
3. Using a syringe rather than a droppper-tip bottle. With practice, you can use a lot less resin but as in example #2, you rely on the physical qualities of the crack to get it to properly fill. You could be proactive and set up a crack expander tool at potential trouble points, but there is no reliable way to tell if or where a crack will "tighten up".
4. Moving the bridge and injector along the crack from drilled tip to impact point or edge of glass and injecting resin under pressure. This is the most reliable technique that I've used and is the one I use almost exclusively. When I was working a lot more there were years when I was repairing well over three hundred cracks over six inches long. There are a lot of tips and tricks relative to using this technique that make it consistently successful and profitable. I spent two or three years of of trial and error and experimentation and a few hundred substandard long crack repairs before I was satisfied with the reliablility of the process. If anyone is really serious about repairing long cracks (more than 7 inches) I recommend this technique without reservation. However, you need a bridge that you can move smoothly, an acceptable lubricant for the cups and the correct lubrication technique (hint: it's not KY jelly, water, hand lotion or vaseline), an injector seal that allows you to achieve the needed pressure and for ease of execution a traditional screw-type injector, although some of the more recent injector designs might work as well with sufficient practice. The further you initially mount the suction cups from the tip of the crack, the less chance there is for the crack to spread. Mount the cups closer to the impact point or the edge of the glass and slide the bridge toward the drill hole at the tip before beginning the repair. Also, when mounting the bridge over the drilled tip prior to injection, do not line up the injector, cup (suction or vacuum) and the leveling bolt(s) on the same axis as the direction of travel, ie: in line with the crack. Mount the structure along the side of the crack. This lessens the potential for the crack to spread. And finally, whatever technique you choose ALWAYS start at the tip of the crack and work toward the impact point or the edge of the glass. Working from the impact point or glass edge toward the tip is less reliable, more frustrating, will normally require more "fix-up" steps (which costs you money and time), and does not inspire confidence.
1. Injecting the resin under pressure with a bridge and injector, watching the resin travel as far as the pressure would allow (roughly four inches), drilling again, injecting again, etc, etc. Obviously not a recommended practice. I quit using that technique about 1988 or 89.
2. Drilling the tip, injecting resin, observing how far the resin traveled and then continuing on by running the dropper tip of the resin bottle along the crack. This is a very messy technique and wastes an enormous amount of resin (not that your resin supplier would complain). I learned to somewhat compensate for the wasted resin by catching the drips with a razor blade and feeding the resin to the crack by moving the blade. Overall, this technique demonstrates inconsistent results. In order for it to work you need a crack that's sufficiently surfaced along it's entire length so that the resin can wick into the damage by capillary action. Curves and "zig-zaggy" areas generally are too tight for capillary action to work although sometimes you get lucky.
3. Using a syringe rather than a droppper-tip bottle. With practice, you can use a lot less resin but as in example #2, you rely on the physical qualities of the crack to get it to properly fill. You could be proactive and set up a crack expander tool at potential trouble points, but there is no reliable way to tell if or where a crack will "tighten up".
4. Moving the bridge and injector along the crack from drilled tip to impact point or edge of glass and injecting resin under pressure. This is the most reliable technique that I've used and is the one I use almost exclusively. When I was working a lot more there were years when I was repairing well over three hundred cracks over six inches long. There are a lot of tips and tricks relative to using this technique that make it consistently successful and profitable. I spent two or three years of of trial and error and experimentation and a few hundred substandard long crack repairs before I was satisfied with the reliablility of the process. If anyone is really serious about repairing long cracks (more than 7 inches) I recommend this technique without reservation. However, you need a bridge that you can move smoothly, an acceptable lubricant for the cups and the correct lubrication technique (hint: it's not KY jelly, water, hand lotion or vaseline), an injector seal that allows you to achieve the needed pressure and for ease of execution a traditional screw-type injector, although some of the more recent injector designs might work as well with sufficient practice. The further you initially mount the suction cups from the tip of the crack, the less chance there is for the crack to spread. Mount the cups closer to the impact point or the edge of the glass and slide the bridge toward the drill hole at the tip before beginning the repair. Also, when mounting the bridge over the drilled tip prior to injection, do not line up the injector, cup (suction or vacuum) and the leveling bolt(s) on the same axis as the direction of travel, ie: in line with the crack. Mount the structure along the side of the crack. This lessens the potential for the crack to spread. And finally, whatever technique you choose ALWAYS start at the tip of the crack and work toward the impact point or the edge of the glass. Working from the impact point or glass edge toward the tip is less reliable, more frustrating, will normally require more "fix-up" steps (which costs you money and time), and does not inspire confidence.